How To Analyze A Creative Finance Deal In Under 60 Seconds.
Seller finance, subject-to, wrap, or rent-to-own: every creative finance deal answers the same six questions. This is the exact method the free CFP Deal Analyzer runs on every deal, and you can run it yourself with three numbers and a phone.
Get Free Instant Access
Enter your name, email, and phone and the Deal Analyzer is yours, free, on your phone or desktop, ready for your next seller call.
By submitting you agree to receive emails & SMS from Creative Finance Playbook. Unsubscribe anytime.
The 6-Step Analysis
Run these in order. Each step either strengthens the deal or tells you exactly what to renegotiate.
Get three numbers
Purchase price, monthly payment (PITI: principal, interest, taxes, insurance), and market rent. Everything else builds on these.
Find the spread
Market rent minus the monthly payment. $300+ a month is strong, $100 to $300 is tight, below $100 renegotiate the terms before going further.
Stress test it
Apply a vacancy rate (8% is about one empty month a year) and a maintenance reserve (1% of purchase price a year). A spread that survives both is real.
Total the cost of entry
Down payment, back payments or liens, closing costs, repairs, first-year insurance, plus a 3-month payment reserve. This is the real price of the deal.
Compute cash-on-cash
Annual cash flow divided by cost of entry. 8 to 10 percent is solid. Creative finance deals often beat that because the entry cash is smaller.
Compare both exits
Standard rental vs rent-to-own on the same deal. A tenant-buyer's option deposit can recover most or all of your entry cost on move-in day.
How The 0-100 Deal Score Works
The CFP Deal Analyzer scores every deal on four weighted components.
| Component | Weight | Maxes out at |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cash flow | 30 points | $500+ monthly spread |
| Cash-on-cash return | 25 points | 15%+ return |
| Rent-to-own boost | 30 points | Deposit covers full cost of entry |
| Market fit | 15 points | Spread is 20%+ of rent |
What Each Band Tells You To Do
The score is a decision, and the component bars show which lever to pull when it falls short.
80 and above
Strong numbers across the board. Verify your rent estimate against actual listings, then move on the deal.
50 to 79
The deal has a weak component: usually a thin spread or too much cash in. Renegotiate the payment, the price, or the deposit and re-run it.
Below 50
Walk away. A low score at asking terms is the signal to counter with terms that work, or spend your time on the next deal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is creative financing in real estate?
Creative financing means buying real estate without a new bank loan: seller financing, buying subject to the existing mortgage, wrap mortgages, and lease options (rent-to-own). The seller's terms replace the bank's terms, which is why the numbers have to be analyzed deal by deal.
What numbers do I need to analyze a deal?
Only three to start: purchase price, monthly payment (PITI: principal, interest, taxes, insurance), and market rent. For a full analysis, add down payment, back payments or liens, closing costs, renovation budget, first-year insurance, and a rent-to-own option deposit.
What is a good monthly spread?
A monthly spread of $300 or more between market rent and the total monthly payment is strong, $100 to $300 is tight, and below $100 the deal needs renegotiation. The spread should also survive realistic vacancy and maintenance adjustments.
What is cash-on-cash return?
Cash-on-cash return is your annual cash flow divided by the total cash you put into the deal. If a deal produces $4,800 a year in cash flow and took $40,000 to acquire, the cash-on-cash return is 12%. Creative finance deals often reach far higher returns because the cash to enter is smaller.
How does a rent-to-own exit change the analysis?
A rent-to-own tenant buyer pays a non-refundable option deposit at move-in, typically 5 to 10 percent of the purchase price. That deposit recovers part or all of your cost of entry, so the same monthly cash flow produces a much higher cash-on-cash return, sometimes putting you back to even on move-in day.
What makes a deal score high?
The deal score weighs four things: monthly cash flow (30 points), cash-on-cash return (25 points), the rent-to-own deposit's coverage of your entry cost (30 points), and market fit, meaning spread as a share of rent (15 points). A deal scoring 80 or above is strong; below 50 says walk away.
Get free instant access to the CFP Deal Analyzer. Enter your info once and start running numbers in the next 60 seconds.
Get The Free Calculator ↑The information and results provided by this real estate investing calculator are for educational and informational purposes only and do not constitute financial, legal, or investment advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy of the inputs and formulas, all calculations are estimates and may not reflect actual market conditions, investment returns, costs, or financial outcomes. Real estate investments involve risks, and your actual results may vary based on factors such as interest rates, property appreciation, vacancy rates, expenses, tax implications, and financing terms. Before making any financial decisions or real estate purchases, consult with a licensed financial advisor, real estate professional, attorney, or tax advisor. You are solely responsible for your use of this tool and any resulting decisions or outcomes. Use of this calculator does not create a client relationship with its creators, and we disclaim any liability for loss or damages of any kind arising from reliance on the calculator's output.